The Dark Night of the Soul: Meaning, Signs, and How to Move Through It
What the dark night of the soul really is — its origins in St John of the Cross, common signs, how it differs from depression, and what helps.
If you are in crisis: if you are having thoughts of ending your life or harming yourself, please reach out now. In the US, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline). In the UK and Ireland, call Samaritans on 116 123. Elsewhere, contact your local emergency number. You do not have to work out what you are going through before asking for help.
There is a particular kind of darkness that does not look like a crisis from the outside. Life carries on. Work gets done. Meals are cooked. But inside, something that used to hold everything together has gone quiet. The prayers that once felt like conversation now feel like talking into an empty room. The practices that once nourished you taste of nothing. The beliefs, values, or sense of purpose that organised your life no longer seem to bear weight — and nothing has yet arrived to replace them.
For centuries, people in this condition have reached for a phrase coined by a sixteenth-century Spanish friar: the dark night of the soul. It has since travelled far beyond its origins, into psychology, popular spirituality, and ordinary speech. It is used, sometimes, for things it was never meant to describe.
This guide is an attempt to treat the subject carefully. It explains where the phrase comes from and what it originally meant, how it is used today, the signs people commonly describe, how it differs from clinical depression — which matters a great deal — and what tends to help.
What is the dark night of the soul?#
The dark night of the soul is a period of profound spiritual dryness, disorientation, or loss of meaning, in which familiar sources of comfort, faith, and purpose seem to fall away. The phrase comes from the Spanish mystic St John of the Cross, who described it as a painful but ultimately transformative stage of spiritual growth. Today it is often used more broadly for any deep existential crisis in which old certainties collapse before a new way of living has formed.
The key word in the original meaning is transformative. For John of the Cross, the dark night was not a breakdown of the spiritual life but a passage within it — a stripping away of what is secondhand, comfortable, or immature, so that something truer can grow.
Where the phrase comes from#
John of the Cross (1542–1591) was a Carmelite friar and poet who worked alongside Teresa of Ávila to reform the Carmelite order in Spain. In December 1577, friars opposed to the reform seized him and imprisoned him in a monastery in Toledo, in a cell so small he could barely stand. He was held for about eight months, beaten regularly, and given almost no light. In August 1578 he escaped.
Around that time he wrote a short poem beginning En una noche oscura — "On a dark night." It describes a soul slipping out of a sleeping house, unseen, in darkness, to meet its beloved. It is a love poem, and an astonishingly joyful one. At its centre are the lines:
¡Oh noche que guiaste!
¡oh noche amable más que la alborada!
O night that guided me! O night more lovely than the dawn!
This is the first thing most people do not know about the dark night: in its original setting, the night is the guide. It is painful, disorienting, and frightening — but it is also the means by which the soul is led somewhere it could not have reached in daylight.
Years later John wrote a long prose commentary on the poem, now known as The Dark Night. In it he describes two nights. The first, the night of the senses, is when consolation drains out of religious practice: prayer that once felt sweet becomes dry, and the person can no longer meditate as before. The second, the night of the spirit, goes deeper — a sense of abandonment, emptiness, and even of God's absence, which John understood paradoxically as God working most intimately, beyond what the mind can perceive.
John was clear that these nights are not punishments, and that the person going through them is usually doing nothing wrong. The dryness is a sign of transition, not failure.
How the phrase is used today#
Over the past few decades, dark night of the soul has broadened considerably. Spiritual teachers such as Eckhart Tolle use it for any collapse of meaning that precedes a deeper awakening. Therapists and writers use it for existential crises — the loss of a worldview, a vocation, a faith, a long-held identity. In everyday speech it is sometimes simply a dramatic way of saying "a very hard time."
Some of this broadening is useful. Many people who would never use the language of Carmelite mysticism do pass through periods in which the whole structure of meaning they lived inside falls apart — after bereavement, illness, divorce, a crisis of faith, a mid-life reckoning, or for no visible reason at all. The phrase gives them a way to say that this is a recognised human passage, not a private malfunction.
But broadening also blurs. It can lead people to romanticise what is actually clinical depression, or to treat every bad patch as a spiritual initiation. Sometimes what feels like a dark night is closer to plain exhaustion — the inner life depleted by years of giving — which we cover in our guide to spiritual burnout. The original concept is more specific — and, in its specificity, more helpful.
Even among the most devoted, the experience is not rare. When the private letters of Mother Teresa of Calcutta were published in 2007, in the book Come Be My Light, readers were astonished to learn that for nearly fifty years she had felt an almost constant sense of God's absence — while continuing her work with unwavering faithfulness. Darkness of this kind, it seems, can coexist with a deeply meaningful life.
Common signs of a dark night of the soul#
People who describe going through a dark night tend to report several of the following:
- Spiritual practices go dry. Prayer, meditation, worship, or reading that once felt alive now feels empty or mechanical.
- Old beliefs no longer fit. Ideas about God, life, or yourself that once seemed solid now feel hollow, naive, or simply gone.
- A loss of meaning. Goals and ambitions that once drove you seem pointless; you are not sure what your life is for.
- A sense of being stripped. Identities, roles, and certainties seem to be falling away one by one.
- Disorientation. You cannot go back to how things were, and you cannot yet see what comes next.
- A strange persistent longing. Despite the emptiness, a quiet desire for something real — truth, depth, God, home — remains, sometimes stronger than before.
- Loneliness of a particular kind. A sense that the people around you cannot quite reach where you are.
- Little interest in the old consolations. The things that used to cheer you up — entertainment, achievement, socialising — feel thin.
That last point overlaps heavily with depression, which is why the next section matters.
Dark night of the soul or depression?#
This is the most important question in this guide, and it deserves a careful answer.
A dark night of the soul is not a recognised medical diagnosis. Depression is — and it is common, serious, and treatable. The two can look alike from the inside, they can overlap, and one can lead into the other. You do not have to decide which one you are experiencing before seeking help, and seeking help does not mean your experience lacks spiritual significance.
The psychiatrist Gerald May, who spent much of his career at the meeting point of psychology and contemplative spirituality, wrote a thoughtful book on the subject — The Dark Night of the Soul (2004). In his reading, people in a dark night often keep certain things that clinical depression tends to erode: their sense of humour, their compassion for others, their ability to function in daily life, and some underlying sense — however faint — that the darkness is going somewhere. Depression, by contrast, more often brings a pervasive heaviness, self-criticism or self-loathing, and an impaired ability to get through ordinary days. May was equally clear that the two can coexist, and that a dark night does not make anyone immune to depression.
As a practical guide, please speak to a doctor or mental-health professional — promptly — if you notice any of the following:
- Low mood, emptiness, or loss of interest in almost everything, most of the day, nearly every day, for two weeks or more.
- Significant changes in sleep or appetite, or persistent exhaustion.
- Strong feelings of worthlessness, guilt, or hopelessness.
- Difficulty concentrating, working, or caring for yourself or others.
- Thoughts of death, of not wanting to be here, or of harming yourself.
If you are experiencing thoughts of suicide, please contact a crisis line immediately (in the US, call or text 988; in the UK and Ireland, Samaritans on 116 123).
Getting treatment for depression does not cancel the spiritual dimension of what you are going through. Many people find that therapy, medication, or both lift enough of the weight that the deeper spiritual questions can finally be faced, rather than simply endured. Ideally, look for a therapist who is comfortable with questions of meaning and faith, and consider pairing therapy with a spiritual director or chaplain.
What tends to help#
There is no technique that ends a dark night on schedule. But the people who have walked through one — and the traditions that have accompanied them for centuries — agree on a number of things that help.
Keep a minimal practice, and stop forcing it#
John of the Cross advised people in the night of the senses not to strain after the old feelings. Keep showing up — a few minutes of silence, a short prayer, a single line of a psalm or poem — but stop trying to make it feel the way it used to. The practice is no longer about what you get from it. It is a way of remaining available. Our guide to the practice of returning describes this kind of quiet faithfulness.
Tell at least one person#
Darkness thrives in isolation. Find one person you can speak to honestly — a friend, a partner, a faith leader, a therapist. You do not need them to fix anything. You need them to know. We have written about the courage of being known, and about the kind of friends who simply walk you home.
Find a guide#
Spiritual direction exists precisely for passages like this. A spiritual director is someone trained to accompany people through their inner life without imposing answers; many work across faiths or with people of no faith. Organisations such as Spiritual Directors International maintain directories. A thoughtful chaplain, minister, rabbi, imam, or meditation teacher can play the same role.
Look after the body#
The body carries the soul through the night. Sleep, regular meals, daylight, and movement do not solve existential questions, but their absence makes every question heavier. Gentle daily walking is especially helpful — see our guide to walking meditation. And prioritise rest: sleep is an ethical act, never more so than in hard seasons.
Let old forms go#
Part of what makes a dark night painful is the effort to hold onto beliefs, practices, or identities that no longer fit. Sometimes the most helpful thing is to grieve them honestly and let them go — without rushing to find replacements. We have written about this in Letting the Fire Go Out and The Uses of Grief.
Make no irreversible decisions in the dark#
St Ignatius of Loyola, a near-contemporary of John of the Cross, gave a rule that has proved its worth for five centuries: in a time of desolation, do not make major changes. Do not abandon a marriage, a vocation, or a community because everything feels empty right now. Wait. Hold steady. Decide later, from a clearer place. (Our guide to the daily examen explains this Ignatian wisdom in more depth.)
Read those who have been there#
There is real companionship in the writing of people who have walked this road: John of the Cross himself, Teresa of Ávila, the letters of Mother Teresa, Simone Weil, the Psalms of lament, Gerald May's book, Barbara Brown Taylor's Learning to Walk in the Dark. Read slowly, a little at a time. Our guide to reading as a spiritual discipline may help.
Practise not knowing#
Perhaps the hardest instruction of all: allow yourself not to have an answer. The dark night is, in large part, the experience of the old answers failing. The temptation is to grab the first new answer that appears. Resist it. Live inside the question for a while. We have written about the art of not knowing and the dignity of being not yet finished.
What tends not to help#
- Forced positivity. Being told to "look on the bright side" or "trust the process" by people who have not been there usually deepens isolation.
- Spiritual bypassing. Using spiritual language to avoid real pain, grief, or psychological need — including avoiding treatment for depression.
- Frantic seeking. Racing from teacher to teacher, retreat to retreat, book to book, in search of the experience that will switch the lights back on.
- Self-blame. Assuming that the darkness means you have failed, sinned, or done the practice wrong. John of the Cross was emphatic on this point: the night is not a verdict.
- Total isolation. Withdrawing from everyone because no one could possibly understand.
How long does a dark night of the soul last?#
There is no fixed duration. John of the Cross suggested that the deeper night could last for years. Mother Teresa's lasted, by her own account, for most of her adult life. In modern accounts, people more commonly describe a period of several months to a few years, often with gradual rather than sudden easing.
It also rarely ends cleanly. More often, people describe the darkness slowly becoming less frightening, then more familiar, then — almost imperceptibly — a different kind of light. Not a return to the old certainties, but something quieter and more durable.
What waits on the other side#
It would be dishonest to promise that a dark night always ends in illumination. Some people come through it with their old faith restored; some with a different faith; some with no faith but a deeper peace; some simply changed in ways they find hard to describe.
But certain themes recur in the accounts of those who have passed through. A simpler, less anxious relationship with what they hold sacred. Less need for certainty. More compassion for others who suffer. A faith — religious or otherwise — that is lived rather than performed. The philosopher Paul Ricoeur called something like this a "second naïveté": a trust that has passed through doubt and criticism and come out the other side, not by ignoring them, but by going through them.
In the language of mid-life, it can be the valley between the first mountain and the second. In the language of the seasons, it is winter — and winter, however long, is not the end of the year. (Some people find that marking the winter solstice, the longest night, gives the experience a shape it otherwise lacks.)
Frequently asked questions#
What does "dark night of the soul" mean?#
The phrase comes from St John of the Cross, a sixteenth-century Spanish mystic, who used it to describe a painful but transformative stage of spiritual growth in which familiar comforts and certainties fall away. Today it is commonly used for any deep period of spiritual dryness, existential crisis, or loss of meaning that precedes inner change.
What are the signs of a dark night of the soul?#
Commonly described signs include spiritual practices feeling dry or empty, old beliefs no longer making sense, a loss of meaning and motivation, a feeling of being stripped of identity and certainty, disorientation about the future, and — often — a persistent longing for something deeper. Many of these overlap with depression, so it is wise to speak to a professional if they are persistent or severe.
Is the dark night of the soul the same as depression?#
No, though they can look similar and can occur together. A dark night of the soul is a spiritual concept, not a medical diagnosis; depression is a common and treatable health condition. If you have low mood, loss of interest, sleep or appetite changes, hopelessness, or thoughts of self-harm lasting two weeks or more, please see a doctor or mental-health professional. You can seek treatment and still honour the spiritual meaning of what you are going through.
How long does the dark night of the soul last?#
It varies widely. Some people describe months; others, years. St John of the Cross suggested the deepest stage could last a long time, and Mother Teresa's letters describe decades of spiritual darkness. It usually eases gradually rather than ending suddenly.
Can you go through a dark night of the soul if you are not religious?#
Yes. While the term comes from Christian mysticism, many non-religious people describe very similar experiences — the collapse of a worldview, identity, or sense of purpose, followed by a slow reconstruction of meaning. The guidance in this article applies whether or not you have a faith.
What should I do during a dark night of the soul?#
Keep a small, gentle practice without forcing it; talk honestly to at least one person; consider a spiritual director and, if needed, a therapist; look after your sleep, food, and movement; avoid irreversible decisions; read the writers who have been there; and allow yourself not to have answers for a while. If you have any thoughts of harming yourself, contact a crisis line or doctor immediately.
A final word#
If you are in the dark right now, this article cannot switch on the light. Nothing written can. But perhaps it can offer one thing: the knowledge that you are not the first. People have walked this road for as long as there have been people. Some of them wrote it down. Many of them, in time, came to speak of the night not only as something they survived, but as something that led them — slowly, painfully, unseen — somewhere they could not have found by daylight.
Be gentle with yourself. Let someone know. Keep a small light, even if you cannot feel its warmth. And do not decide, tonight, what the darkness means.
May you be accompanied. May you be patient with what you cannot yet see. May the night, in its own time, become a guide.